Maybe I’m becoming a cranky, old man ahead of schedule. Maybe watching so many games at Coors Field has made me hypersensitive to how the ball plays at newer ballparks. Maybe I just grew up at a time when crummy ballparks were readily identifiable by patchy AstroTurf and circular shape. Whatever the cause, I’ve got a beef with some of the ballparks that have been churned out over the last 12 years or so. None of these stadia draw my ire more than Minute Maid Park, home of the Houston Astros and host to the Rockies this last weekend.
The new generation of ballparks started innocently enough in Baltimore, Cleveland, then Denver with ballparks intended to combine state-of-the-art convenience for players and fans with an old-timey baseball look that blended into the park’s neighborhood. The idea caught on, and Major League cities everywhere were adopting variations on the concept. By the turn of the millenium, some of the newest parks looked like little Disney Worlds with a lot of red brick and steel. In the middle of it all somewhere, each of these ballparks had a bandbox of a baseball field. If the Tilt-A-Whirl doesn’t bring in the crowds, surely the home run ball will! (I’m aware of the irony of this coming from a Rockies fan, but the issue at Coors is physics rather than intent.)
Some of the newest parks were also built as retractable domes, which means the little brick and steel Disney World was crammed into a warehouse. In most of these domes, it’s immediately clear that field shape was an afterthought in the design. The outfield walls jut out at bizarre angles to accommodate the warehouse structures and outfield pavilions and big hot tubs and playground slides for the team mascot. There are even overhangs where home run territory extends over the outfield. Inevitably, there will be yellow lines painted on or immediately in front of some walls that will make it unreasonably difficult for umpires to make accurate calls.
Minute Maid Field seems to be the poster structure for everything that’s wrong with this generation of retractable domes. It’s got the bizarre angles, the impossible home run calls, a tiny left field porch, and even a flagpole in center field! Don’t worry though, no center fielders are going to run blindly into the flagpole on the field, because they’ll tear their ACLs to shreds before they get there.
The knee (and sometimes ankle) injuries are courtesy of Tal’s Hill, a 10-degree grass slope that awkwardly rests at the base of the wall in dead center. You might recall the Rockies trip to Houston last season, where former Astro Willy Taveras was injured making a play on Tal’s Hill. The problem with the hill is that it demands that oncoming fielders immediately adjust to a 10-degree change to the flat plane they’ve been on all game. But the center fielder already has enough to worry about with tracking the fly ball and likely running. It’s a torqued knee and a face full of grass waiting to happen.
For the record: I definitely support the concept of a sloped approach to the wall in the outfield, but it’s executed poorly in Houston. They need a gradual slope to give the fielder time to adjust. If done right (and sans flagpole), it could be goodbye re-constructive surgery, hello web gem!
I also don’t like the hokey names that are quickly replacing baseball terminology at Minute Maid Park. Part of center field has been replaced with a topographical feature with a dude’s name. A home run to left field (which seem to happen at least every other inning) usually lands in the Crawford Boxes that sit in what should probably be more left field. It’s just a matter of time before the right-center gap is known only as Pecos Valley. The only thing that could be cornier is if they put a fake train on top of a wall and ran it down a short track after every Astros home run. Oh right, they’ve already got that covered.

The point is that it’s time we started referring to the place as Enron Field again. The parallels are too obvious to pass up this opportunity. On face, things look pretty solid and attractive. Look how shiny and high budget everything is: these guys must know what they’re doing! But then you get a little deeper into things to find that it’s all poorly conceived and ill-equipped to carry out its primary function…
On second thought, maybe the Crawford Boxes can stay.
Latest Comments